NOS A3817?

wsfarrell
Posts
2,443
Likes
4,225
He probably hit the shiny parts with some Mother's Mag, but those two marks on the (brushed) left side of the case suggest he DIDN'T polish with a power tool, or those would have been brushed out.
 
Zuke
Posts
973
Likes
1,725
Great looking watch, just don't call it NOS.
Edited:
 
Darlinboy
Posts
8,741
Likes
69,398
Redone case, and not well.:(

Nice dial.

Crazy asking price.
 
ezinternet
Posts
242
Likes
2,020
I'm sure the forum abounds in similar pictures, but just as a point of reference in the thread ... I think this is an example (other watch of course) of what a(n) (darn-close-to since I-wasn't-there-since-the-day-it-was-sold) unpolished case might look like.

-Ez

A384 Case.jpg El P A384 bevel.jpg
 
sgtpry
Posts
338
Likes
3,921
I did a little bit of research on Zenith A3817

I focused on the case edge finish on Zenith A3817, should it be ruler straight or not...

Modern Zenith with similar tonneau shaped case indeed has ruler straight edges (done by high precision modern tools),
but in the late 60s and early 70s, these edges done manually by human hands with simpler tools (not as precise as current modern tools)

I then exchanged email sending pictures of curvy wavy edges finish on above Zenith A3817 with a famous and well respected watchmaker in Europe which is expert in Heuer, Zenith and other vintage brands.

If he said/write something about vintage Heuer and Zenith, I (and I believe many other collectors) will consider his opinion as true as it gets.

To share this knowledge with our community to help others on hunt of a Zenith A3817 and similar case (A384/A385/A3818), below is the summarized modified (to make it shorter) quote from the expert watchmaker:
- I know how to handle those A384/A385/A3818/A3817 cases
- I have looked at the photos of the A3817…and I am pretty sure about it that it left the factory the way it is
- I have seen about 35 of these cases and most of them had these “strange” "wavy" lines

Hope this small research helps with confusion about case edge finish on Zenith A3817 (A384/A385/A3818), should it be ruler straight or not...
 
LouS
Posts
6,713
Likes
18,550
I know who you spoke to as I've had the same discussion, and I agree that his opinion should at all times be presented in italics, even in boldface, but the market will punish the curved edge.
 
sgtpry
Posts
338
Likes
3,921
Hi Lou

Indeed, it seems like that....although it's originally not straight, market wants ruler straight

What is your opinion, keep it original curvy and wavy

Or get expert service to make it straight?

LouS LouS
I know who you spoke to as I've had the same discussion, and I agree that his opinion should at all times be presented in italics, even in boldface, but the market will punish the curved edge.
 
LouS
Posts
6,713
Likes
18,550
I've elected to have it straightened in the past - just can't live with the curves
 
sgtpry
Posts
338
Likes
3,921
Got it

Thanks for the information!

LouS LouS
I've elected to have it straightened in the past - just can't live with the curves
 
sgtpry
Posts
338
Likes
3,921
JohnSteed JohnSteed
Love that movie...Called 'trouble with the curve' ;)


Indeed John,
I think for me, I will keep the curves untouched, just like how it got out of the factory in 1971
 
sgtpry
Posts
338
Likes
3,921
sneer sneer
My case in ori shape


Very nice, as can be seen, not ruler straight, but originally born that way :)
 
Sign up or log in to reply...